The Italy spyware scandal has raised serious questions about government surveillance press freedom and hacking tools.The case focuses on Graphite, a spyware tool developed by Paragon Solutions.In early 2025 WhatsApp warned users about possible spyware attacks.
Immigration activists and journalist Francesco Cancellato became key figures in the case.New forensic findings emerged in 2026.However investigators still do not know who carried out every attack.
What Happened In The Italy Spyware Scandal?
In January 2025 WhatsApp warned around 90 users about possible spyware targeting.Several people in Italy came forward.They included Luca Casarini and Giuseppe Caccia from the migrant-rescue group Mediterranea Saving Humans.
Graphite can access private information on a targeted phone.It may expose messages and other sensitive data.Therefore its use raises serious privacy concerns.These concerns grow when attacks involve journalists and activists.
What Did Italy’s Parliamentary Investigation Find?
In June 2025 Italy’s parliamentary security committee COPASIR published its findings.The committee said Italian intelligence agencies targeted Casarini and Caccia with Graphite.It also said the agencies had legal authorization.
The surveillance related to investigations into alleged assistance with irregular immigration.However COPASIR found no evidence that Italian intelligence targeted Cancellato.
The committee reviewed agency records and audit logs.It also reported that intelligence agencies suspended the system in February 2025.They later ended their contracts with Paragon.
These findings covered the cases and records that COPASIR examined.However they did not answer every question about the spyware alerts.
New Forensic Findings In 2026
In March 2026 prosecutors in Rome and Naples reported new findings. They discovered malware-related traces on three Android phones. The phones belonged to Cancellato, Casarini, and Caccia.
Prosecutors said Investigators said the timing pointed to a possible single infection campaign.However they did not establish who carried out the attack on Cancellato.They also said they had not found evidence linking that journalist’s infection to Italy’s intelligence services.
This distinction matters.The forensic findings supported the conclusion that Cancellato’s phone had been compromised, while the identity of the attacker remained unknown.They did not prove who ordered the attack.
Why The Investigation Remains Unresolved
A June 2026 investigation by Wired Italia reported that Italian prosecutors were still waiting for technical information from Paragon.The company had not provided substantive answers to formal requests according to the report.
Meanwhile COPASIR’s August 2026 activity report maintained that it found no legal violations by intelligence services in the cases it examined.It also described further reviews of other reported cases.However the committee’s conclusions do not replace separate criminal investigations.
The Italy spyware scandal therefore remains significant for digital privacy and press freedom.Investigators still need to establish who targeted Cancellato and whether other reported victims were affected.Until those questions are answered the case highlights the difficulty of holding spyware operators and suppliers accountable.



